classwarfare

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Wednesday, 27 March 2013

Profitability, the euro crisis and Icelandic myths

Posted on 10:40 by Unknown
by Michael Roberts

As I have said in a previous post (see http://thenextrecession.wordpress.com/2013/03/16/workers-punks-and-the-euro-crisis/), Slovenia is likely to be the next Eurozone state that will require a bailout after Cyprus.  Slovenia’s banks need €1bn for recapitalisation after taking heavy losses on the commercial property development bust and on falling government debt prices (Italy?).  And the new centre-left coalition needs about €3bn to cover the budget deficit and debt repayments this year.  It does not look like it can find this money from the country’s own taxpayers and banks.  So watch this space.

As Cyprus enters a long period of austerity with the banking sector decimated and the economy diving (one forecast is for a 20% fall in real GDP through to 2017), the debate continues.  Is it better for small economies like Cyprus, Slovenia and even Greece to leave the Eurozone, institute their own currencies and devalue against the euro and the dollar, so they can grow through cheaper exports in world markets?  Or is better to continue with the grinding down of living standards under the ‘heel’ of the dreaded Troika?  Does leaving the euro mean that people can avoid a huge loss in jobs, public services and living standards?

My view is that either way, staying in or leaving the euro, will deliver more or less the same result for the majority.  That’s because this crisis is not a crisis of the euro as such but a crisis of the capitalist mode of production.  The way out for for the Eurozone is for austerity to lower the  cost of production in the weaker states to the point where profitability begins to rise and these smaller economies can start to restore economic growth.  The problem with this solution is that this could take a decade (it’s taken years already) and so it may never happen before capitalism enters another global slump – indeed, that may happen precisely because profitability cannot be restored.

There is some progress through austerity within the eurozone.   A key proxy for competitiveness is an economy’s current account, the broadest measure of trade with the rest of the world. It shows improvement across the periphery EMU nations.  The combined account of Greece, Ireland, Italy, Portugal and Spain narrowed to a deficit of 0.6 percent of gross domestic product at the end of last year from 7 percent in 2008 and will be in balance later this year.  While a slide in imports accounts for some of the correction, Greece boosted its exports outside the EU by about 30 percent in the fourth quarter of 2012 from the previous year, while Italy’s rose 13 percent in January from a year ago.    While austerity weakens consumer demand, it can begin to turn round profitability.  For example, Spain has slashed social-security payments from companies, raised the retirement age and made it easier to fire workers.  Portugal has weakened collective bargaining, cut redundancy payments and suspended four national holidays. Greece has pared public-sector wages, lowered the minimum wage, and eased redundancy rules;  and is selling state assets.

A November study by Berenberg, a Brussels-based research group, found unit labor costs fell 10.5 percent from 2009 to 2012 in Greece, 10.3 percent in Ireland, 6 percent in Spain and 6.1 percent in Portugal. Over the entire euro-area they gained 1.5 percent.  Relative labour costs in Spain and Portugal have now dropped below Germany’s for the first time since 2005. This has all helped to raise profitability in 2012 in most ‘austerity’ EMU economies (see graph).  But, with the exception of Ireland, all the peripheral EMU economies still have much lower rates of profit than their peaks before the global crisis of capitalism hit.   However, with the exception of Italy, profitability did recover in 2012.  In the case of Ireland, profitability turned round as early as 2010.
ROP EMU
Why has Ireland done relatively better?  I think there are two reasons.  First reducing unit labour costs in production has a much bigger effect on growth and profits in an economy like Ireland with annual exports equivalent to 100% of GDP compared to 20-40% in the other countries.   Second, unit labour costs were cut so much more easily because of emigration.  Irish youth, especially skilled workers, just left the country for the UK and elsewhere.  Indeed, the turnaround from net immigration (or Irish returning home to a fast-growing ‘Celtic tiger’ before the crisis) to net emigration is truly dramatic.
Net migration -2
Now many Keynesians like Paul Krugman or George Stiglitz argue that the euro crisis is a crisis of the failed project of the euro, not a crisis of capitalism.  So the answer is for the smaller EMU states to leave the euro.  For example, Krugman reckons the answer for the Cypriot people is to leave the euro. “Cyprus should leave the euro. Now.  The reason is straightforward: staying in the euro means an incredibly severe depression, which will last for many years while Cyprus tries to build a new export sector. Leaving the euro, and letting the new currency fall sharply, would greatly accelerate that rebuilding… What’s the path forward? Cyprus needs to have a tourist boom, plus a rapid growth of other exports — my guess would be agriculture as a driver, although I don’t know much about it. The obvious way to get there is through a large devaluation”  (http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/03/26/cyprus-seriously/).  Keynesians bemoan the fact that this advice has not been heeded.

But there is a good reason for this.

Take the example of Iceland.  This tiny island, smaller in population that Cyprus, is not in the eurozone, or even the EU.  But it is used as the model by many Keynesians (see Krugman on Iceland: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/07/08/the-times-does-iceland/)  for Keynesian-style alternative policies, including devaluation.  Krugman argues for “the relevance of the Icelandic sort-of miracle… What it demonstrated was the usefulness of devaluation (and therefore of having your own currency), and the case for temporary capital controls in an emergency. Also the case for letting creditors of private banks gone wild eat the losses.  Iceland did not engage in fiscal stimulus; it didn’t have to, given the kick from a huge depreciation of the currency.  And more broadly, Iceland is a dramatic demonstration of the wrongness of conventional wisdom in these times. .. Iceland broke all the rules, and things are not too bad.“

But did Iceland ‘break all the rules’ and are ‘things now not too bad’?   This is another Icelandic myth according one Icelandic blogger: “people continue to spread the factually dubious statement that Iceland told creditors & IMF to go jump, nationalised banks, arrested the fraudsters, gave debt relief and is now growing very strongly, thanks.  No, Iceland did not tell the IMF to go away (https://www.imf.org/external/country/ISL/).    Iceland didn’t bail out the collapsed banks, but that wasn’t for the want of trying. If you read through the Report of the Special Investigation Commission you’d find out that the Icelandic government tried everything it could to save the banks, including asking for insane loans to pay off the banks’ debts (http://sic.althingi.is/).   The short version is that they tried to save the banks, save the creditors and screwed up completely.   Iceland arrested a few bank fraudsters, but just the pawns, small fry, and the lackeys.

Yes, Iceland did nationalise its banks but then privatised them again in record time. Two out of the three collapsed major banks in Iceland are now owned by their creditors, not the state. The third bank, Landsbanki, is still nationalised but that’s solely because of ongoing court cases involving Icesave.  Most of the creditors actually sold their stakes onto foreign hedge funds.  Some of the bankrupt banks only remained in government control for a few weeks.  SPRON, for example, was merged into Arion Bank which in turn was given to its creditors a few weeks later. essentially a free gift to Kaupthing’s foreign creditors.

Iceland’s lauded recovery model involving devaluation of its currency coupled with capital controls is now a drag on growth.   Iceland is growing at 2 percent, faster than much of Europe. But the IMF had originally forecast annual growth of around 4.5 percent from 2011-2013. It now is under half that.  Many Icelanders say they do not ‘feel’ this modest growth. Outside booming fishing and tourism, businesses complain of stagnation.  Some 80 percent of households are swamped in housing loan debts indexed to inflation. Investment is under 15 percent of GDP, a record low. State workers like nurses are raising worries about inflation amid increasing demands for better salaries.  An hour’s drive from the capital to the town of Keflavik, dozens of Icelanders line up for free food aid. People must present rent or mortgage slips and their salary slips. Real incomes have dropped sharply for Icelandic households and their debt is index-linked to inflation. Pre-tax gross income of the average Icelander has decreased by 18.3% since 2007. Measured in USD however, the fall is 42.7% since 2007.

So both austerity and Keynesian-style devaluation have resulted in a sharp fall in living standards, whether in Greece or Iceland.

Restoring profitability is key for economic recovery under the capitalist mode of production.  So which pro-capitalist policy has done best on this criterion?  Let’s compare Greece and Iceland.  Iceland’s rate of profit plummeted from 2005 and eventually the island’s property boom burst and along with it the banks collapsed in 2008-9.  Devaluation of the currency started in 2008, but profitability in 2012 remains well under the peak level of 2004, although there has been a slow recovery in profitability from 2008 onwards.  Greece’s profitability stayed up until the global crisis took hold and then it plummeted and only stopped falling last year.  Profitability in ‘austerity’ Greece and ‘devaluing’ Iceland is now about the same relative to 2005 levels.  So you could say that either policy has been equally useless.
ROP GRE-ICE
Perhaps the biggest lesson of this crisis of capitalism is the lasting damage that the Great Recession and the subsequent Long Depression has had on the ability of the capitalist mode of production to deliver on profitability and economic growth.  A recent study found that there has been a significant deterioration in long-term real GDP growth (http://www.voxeu.org/article/eurozone-looking-growth).   Trend growth for the four main Eurozone countries is forecast to be a little less than 1% and slightly less than 2% after 2014, with trend growth highest in Spain and France; and the lowest for Italy and Germany.
Weak trend growth in a central scenario

Source: BofAML Global Research.
It could be even worse, if investment fails to recover quickly. Trend growth might well remain negative in Spain and Italy and may fail to increase for Germany or France.   As the authors conclude, “this exercise shows the damage will indeed be long lasting, permanently impairing growth in a context of an ageing population that needs higher growth capacity than ever before.”
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in economics, EU, marxism, profits | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Amtrak: Washington DC to Huntington, West Virginia
    A Poem by Kevin Higgins   At Union Station hope is a t-shirt on sale at seventy per cent off. Yesterday, all the bow-tied barristers gather...
  • The NSA, Snowden, spying on Americans, Brazilians and everyone else
    We reprint this article by Glenn Greenwald which includes the video . It is from the Guardian UK via Reader Supported News . The Charlie R...
  • Austerity USA Begins March 1st:
    We reprint this article for the interest of our readers. Facts For Working People is not affiliated with Workers' Action. To read more f...
  • Starvation, poverty and disease are market driven.
    by Richard Mellor Afscme Local 444, retired What a tragedy. A beautiful little boy who should be experiencing all the pleasures that a heal...
  • Kaiser cancelled from AFL-CIO convention
    A short CNA clip from Kaiser nurses.  The AFL-CIO convention was apparently ready to applaud kaiser as the model health care provider.  The ...
  • Remembering 911
  • Buffet and Lemann: two peas in pod
    Jorge Lemann: won't eat what he produces by Richard Mellor GED Afscme local 444, retired In a previous piece I commen...
  • A poem on the 74th Anniversary of Trotsky's murder
                                                                                  You Are The Old Man In The Blue House                        ...
  • Cambodians clash with cops over land grabs
    Like China, there are repeated clashes between authorities and the population over the government's seizure of land for developers. Ther...
  • Austerity hits troops as rations are cut
    The organizers of this blog have explained that US capitalism cannot afford to keep its massive military machine working at its present leve...

Categories

  • Afghanistan (4)
  • Africa (8)
  • Afscme 444 (1)
  • anti-war movement (1)
  • art (6)
  • asia (15)
  • austerity (29)
  • Australia (4)
  • auto industry (3)
  • bailout (10)
  • bangladesh (9)
  • banks (11)
  • BART (13)
  • body image (4)
  • bradley Manning (17)
  • Britain (22)
  • California (17)
  • california public sector (18)
  • Canada (6)
  • capitalism (44)
  • catholic church (10)
  • child abuse. (1)
  • China (2)
  • consciousness (3)
  • debt (3)
  • Democrats (4)
  • domestic violence (7)
  • drug industry (6)
  • economics (43)
  • education (9)
  • Egypt (5)
  • energy (7)
  • environment (12)
  • EU (18)
  • family (1)
  • financialization (1)
  • food production (7)
  • gay rights (2)
  • globalization (17)
  • greece (3)
  • gun rights (4)
  • health care (13)
  • homelessness (4)
  • housing (3)
  • hugo chavez (4)
  • human nature (6)
  • humor (4)
  • immigration (2)
  • imperialism (14)
  • india (4)
  • indigenous movement (4)
  • Internet (1)
  • iran (4)
  • Iraq (4)
  • ireland (22)
  • Israel/Palestine (13)
  • Italy (3)
  • Japan (7)
  • justice system (11)
  • labor (15)
  • Latin America (17)
  • marxism (52)
  • mass media (4)
  • mass transit (1)
  • Mexico (4)
  • middle east (24)
  • minimum wage (4)
  • movie reviews (1)
  • music (2)
  • nationalism (2)
  • NEA (1)
  • Nigeria (1)
  • non-union (11)
  • nuclear (3)
  • Oakland (5)
  • Obama (14)
  • occupy oakland (2)
  • occupy wall street (1)
  • oil industry (2)
  • OUSD (1)
  • Pakistan (3)
  • Pensions (2)
  • police brutality (6)
  • politicians (6)
  • politics (22)
  • pollution (11)
  • poverty (7)
  • prisons (8)
  • privatization (6)
  • profits (21)
  • protectionism (2)
  • public education (9)
  • public sector (15)
  • public workers (6)
  • racism (18)
  • rape (2)
  • Religion (10)
  • Russia (1)
  • San Leandro (2)
  • sexism (21)
  • sexual violence (2)
  • Snowden (7)
  • socialism (22)
  • soldiers (1)
  • solidarity (1)
  • South Africa (15)
  • Spain (2)
  • speculation (1)
  • sport (2)
  • strikes (35)
  • students (3)
  • surveillance (1)
  • Syria (9)
  • tax the rich (4)
  • taxes (1)
  • Teachers (6)
  • Team Concept (4)
  • terrorism (22)
  • the right (2)
  • Trayvon Martin (3)
  • turkey (3)
  • UAW (3)
  • unemployment (1)
  • union-busting (3)
  • unions (51)
  • US economy (22)
  • us elections (6)
  • US foreign policy (41)
  • US military (26)
  • veterans (1)
  • wall street criminals (13)
  • War (15)
  • wealth (9)
  • wikileaks (12)
  • women (26)
  • worker's party (2)
  • worker's struggle (65)
  • workers (44)
  • Workers International Network (1)
  • world economy (28)
  • youth (5)
  • Zionism (13)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (410)
    • ►  September (21)
    • ►  August (54)
    • ►  July (55)
    • ►  June (43)
    • ►  May (41)
    • ►  April (49)
    • ▼  March (56)
      • It’s still a bear market
      • Guantanamo Hunger Strikers Being Force Fed
      • Ireland: Working class history, Derry uprising 1969
      • South Africa -- Marikana, New Wave of Struggles --...
      • Profitability, the euro crisis and Icelandic myths
      • The 1% fleeing to tax havens with our money
      • The IDF: The "Most Moral Army in the World".
      • Working class history: The Derry Uprising 1969
      • Marx's ideas will not die
      • Zainab Al-Khawaja:Letter From A Bahraini Prison
      • European Union: Cyprus: sold!
      • South Africa: Cape Town Farmworkers' march
      • Zionists arresting Palestinian children
      • Politicians bought and paid for. Make them wear th...
      • Teachers are not to blame for education crisis; th...
      • Iraq War: A good investment for some
      • Rios Montt trial: Just one of the small fry.
      • South Africa: Miners Struggles---no job losses
      • Life is what we make it. Is that so?
      • Cambodians clash with cops over land grabs
      • Labor hierarchy abandons macho defense for shared ...
      • EuroZone: Cypriot bank heist
      • "Saint" Patricks so called day. An Irish Day.
      • Workers, punks and the euro crisis
      • CCSF rally against the cuts. Tim Paulson, Labor C...
      • Audio recording of Bradley Manning’s statement leaked
      • Break the lockout of ILWU by bosses in Vancouver WA
      • Pope. Last one and this one, viciously pro capital...
      • With Chavez gone, the vultures want back in.
      • It's easier to sign up for combat duty than for he...
      • Investment not consumption; profitability not demand
      • WIN Statement on Crisis in British SWP
      • Crisis in British SWP continues with resignations
      • Socialists and the Labor Bureacracy
      • South Africa: DLF on the legacy of Hugo Chavez
      • Ireland: Trade Union meeting in Dublin
      • The arrogance of Wall Street. From the Horses' Mouth
      • Pepsico wants Eastern Europeans to eat healthy snacks
      • Hugo Chavez funeral. Think about it this way.
      • Venezuela: Greg Palast on Hugo Chavez
      • Global Economy: World growth update
      • Chrysler attack on dissident is about who controls...
      • The Revolution Will Not Be Televised: Chavez, the ...
      • The end of Chavismo?
      • A moment with some relatives
      • War on Iran, War on Terror: No war on homelessness
      • Belgian MP slams War on Terror and Mali intervention
      • Students mired in a sea of debt
      • You can’t make a horse drink
      • Catholic Church. Do not be conned by the theatre a...
      • Chrysler attacks union dissident: UAW leadership d...
      • Wealth inequality in America
      • Palestinians living in an Apartheid state called I...
      • US prisons: Torture chambers
      • More crisis on the horizon as capitalism prepares ...
      • The other Mario and the other Marx
    • ►  February (46)
    • ►  January (45)
  • ►  2012 (90)
    • ►  December (43)
    • ►  November (47)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile