classwarfare

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Friday, 1 March 2013

The other Mario and the other Marx

Posted on 07:11 by Unknown
ECB's Mario Draghi
Mario Monti may have been defeated in Italy’s general election and will not be prime minister by the time this March is over, but the other Italian super Mario is still in place.  Mario Draghi is head of the European Central Bank and responsible for ensuring that Italian capitalism does not go bust.  He stands ready to pump cash into Italian government bonds if financial markets should desert Italy over the next few months and force a new Euro crisis.

So how does Mario see his role as the lender of last resort and, as Atlas-like, the supporter of European capitalism? Well, Mario gave a speech on Tuesday in Bayern, Munich, the home of BMW and the heart of conservative Catholic Germany.  He told his audience at the Catholic Academy, at the time of the resignation Pope Benedict (“a great son of Bavaria”) that the Pope had been very concerned about the ‘ethical’ nature of modern capitalism, and so was he, Mario.  Mario was particularly concerned about the ethical role of the ECB during “the economic and financial crisis that now extends into its fifth year.”

Mario noted that “the crisis has dented people’s confidence in the capacity of markets to generate prosperity for all. It has strained Europe’s social model. Alongside the accumulation of staggering wealth by some, there is widespread economic hardship. Entire countries have been suffering from the consequences of misguided past actions – but also from market forces that are sometimes beyond their control.”   So Mario asked the question of himself and the audience: “what is the right framework for reconciling free enterprise and individual profit motives with concerns for the common good and solidarity with the weak?” 

The answer, Mario, tells us is not to rely on the ‘invisible hand of the market’ to solve all; we need an ethical approach, something that Adam Smith, the father of political economy, was also concerned about.  As a Jesuit, Mario follows that Catholic order’s “fundamental guiding principle: our striving for excellence had to be paired with integrity and a moral message – an ultimate sense of purpose in the service of social justice and fairness….Ultimately, we must be guided by a higher moral standard and a profound belief in creating an economic order that serves every person.”

So who does Mario turn to in the current crisis for a guiding hand towards a ‘moral capitalism’?  “Here I find myself in the company of Marx. Not Karl, but Reinhard. Cardinal Reinhard Marx has rightly insisted that “the economy is not an end in itself, but is in the service of all mankind.”  
At this point, let me tell you who Cardinal Reinhart Marx is.  He is the Archbishop of Munich who wrote a book at the depth of the Great Recession entitled “Das Kapital: A Plea for Man”, named after Karl’s work but designed to reject Karl’s ideas.  Reinhart Marx wants a market economy that is “kinder to the weak and downtrodden” instead of “heaping even more rewards on those who behave immorally.”   As we review the results of the global slump, the grotesque greed of the rich and cruel realities of austerity in Greece, Italy, Spain, Portugal and elsewhere on the ‘weak and downtrodden’ , we would hope that Reinhart can tell us how to reconcile the ‘free market’ and capitalism with “the welfare of the world”.  Unfortunately, I have to tell you that Reinhart in his book provides no answers, except vague platitudes.  At least, he does not repeat the line of the head of Goldman Sachs, Lloyd Blankfein, who when asked whether it was right for his investment bank to make huge amounts of money and deliberately sell financial products to customers knowing they were toxic, Blankfein, as the chief vampire squid of capitalism (but a very devout man), replied that he was “doing God’s work”.

Anyway, Mario went on to explain to his Catholic audience how he applied Reinhart’s ethical principles to his job at the ECB.  You see, Mario told them, the main job of the ECB is establish ‘price stability’ and achieving that was “the basis for a just and fair society. It is a common good for all Europeans.”  And of course, it is true that if there is no inflation, households obtain full purchasing power on what they earn and do not see their savings eroded.  That’s important for those that live on the interest of past savings.  However, the ECB can hardly claim that the current low level of inflation (and even deflation) in Europe is down to the work of Mario and his colleagues.  It is the result of the total collapse of ‘effective demand’ as the Keynesians would put it, or down to a strike by capitalist investment (as we followers of Karl, not Reinhart, might put it).  Balanced against the ‘moral good’ of low inflation lies the ‘moral bad’ of extreme unemployment, collapsing public services and falling real incomes. How do we reconcile these apparent contradictions in a ‘moral way’?

Mario recognises that the ECB was failing.  It was failing to get all the liquidity (money) that it had pumped into the hands of bankers onwards to the wider economy: “our low interest rates have simply not been getting through to people in some parts of the euro area.”  Something  had to be done.  So we come to the great ethical policy of Mario Draghi:  Outright Monetary Transactions (OMT).  OMT is the proposed tool of the ECB to buy the bonds of governments that have been deserted by the ‘free market’.  The ECB will buy as much as is necessary to shore up these governments so they can meet their obligations at reasonable rates of interest and keep economies going.

So far this ‘ethical’ measure has not had to be used because financial markets are still expecting Eurozone governments to enforce austerity.  But moral Mario is ‘concerned’.  After all, “economic adjustment is coming at a heavy social cost.”  Euro area GDP is currently lower than it was in 2008. Almost 19 million people are unemployed – more than the population of the Netherlands.  “Unemployment is a tragedy. It squanders the vitality of our workers. It prevents people from playing a full and meaningful part in society. It induces a sense of hopelessness, which drains the inspiration from our young.”

So what is the moral path out of this slough of despond?  For Mario, it is ‘reform’.  By this, Mario does not mean replacing the ‘free market’ with an organisation of society that benefits the majority who create the wealth, as Karl Marx would have it.  He means a bigger role for the ‘free market’, namely “reforms that make doing business easier. That guarantee that those who owe taxes actually pay taxes. That ensure that public services actually serve the public.”  In practice, these are ‘reforms’ that reduce labour’s rights to work; lower pensions; reduce public services and privatise the rest.
Mario says “it is wrong to claim that countries are undertaking reforms only to please the markets or to satisfy the demands of technocrats in Brussels, Frankfurt or Washington. They are doing it for their own benefit.”  Really?  Who are the ‘reforms’ that attack the incomes of workers and pensioners and the ‘social wage’ beneficial to?  To the majority or to rich tiny minority?  Are the economic policies of the ECB and Eurozone governments that Mario supports really “in the service of humanity” ?
Are they what the good Cardinal Marx would recognise as ‘moral’?   “Capitalism without humanity, solidarity and justice has no morals and no future,” the Cardinal wrote.   Unfortunately for Cardinal Marx and Mario, the history of capitalism cannot be divorced from inhumanity, class division, injustice and immorality – as even the last five years has confirmed. 

So it has no future.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in capitalism, EU, Italy, marxism | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Amtrak: Washington DC to Huntington, West Virginia
    A Poem by Kevin Higgins   At Union Station hope is a t-shirt on sale at seventy per cent off. Yesterday, all the bow-tied barristers gather...
  • The NSA, Snowden, spying on Americans, Brazilians and everyone else
    We reprint this article by Glenn Greenwald which includes the video . It is from the Guardian UK via Reader Supported News . The Charlie R...
  • Austerity USA Begins March 1st:
    We reprint this article for the interest of our readers. Facts For Working People is not affiliated with Workers' Action. To read more f...
  • Starvation, poverty and disease are market driven.
    by Richard Mellor Afscme Local 444, retired What a tragedy. A beautiful little boy who should be experiencing all the pleasures that a heal...
  • Kaiser cancelled from AFL-CIO convention
    A short CNA clip from Kaiser nurses.  The AFL-CIO convention was apparently ready to applaud kaiser as the model health care provider.  The ...
  • Remembering 911
  • Buffet and Lemann: two peas in pod
    Jorge Lemann: won't eat what he produces by Richard Mellor GED Afscme local 444, retired In a previous piece I commen...
  • A poem on the 74th Anniversary of Trotsky's murder
                                                                                  You Are The Old Man In The Blue House                        ...
  • Cambodians clash with cops over land grabs
    Like China, there are repeated clashes between authorities and the population over the government's seizure of land for developers. Ther...
  • Austerity hits troops as rations are cut
    The organizers of this blog have explained that US capitalism cannot afford to keep its massive military machine working at its present leve...

Categories

  • Afghanistan (4)
  • Africa (8)
  • Afscme 444 (1)
  • anti-war movement (1)
  • art (6)
  • asia (15)
  • austerity (29)
  • Australia (4)
  • auto industry (3)
  • bailout (10)
  • bangladesh (9)
  • banks (11)
  • BART (13)
  • body image (4)
  • bradley Manning (17)
  • Britain (22)
  • California (17)
  • california public sector (18)
  • Canada (6)
  • capitalism (44)
  • catholic church (10)
  • child abuse. (1)
  • China (2)
  • consciousness (3)
  • debt (3)
  • Democrats (4)
  • domestic violence (7)
  • drug industry (6)
  • economics (43)
  • education (9)
  • Egypt (5)
  • energy (7)
  • environment (12)
  • EU (18)
  • family (1)
  • financialization (1)
  • food production (7)
  • gay rights (2)
  • globalization (17)
  • greece (3)
  • gun rights (4)
  • health care (13)
  • homelessness (4)
  • housing (3)
  • hugo chavez (4)
  • human nature (6)
  • humor (4)
  • immigration (2)
  • imperialism (14)
  • india (4)
  • indigenous movement (4)
  • Internet (1)
  • iran (4)
  • Iraq (4)
  • ireland (22)
  • Israel/Palestine (13)
  • Italy (3)
  • Japan (7)
  • justice system (11)
  • labor (15)
  • Latin America (17)
  • marxism (52)
  • mass media (4)
  • mass transit (1)
  • Mexico (4)
  • middle east (24)
  • minimum wage (4)
  • movie reviews (1)
  • music (2)
  • nationalism (2)
  • NEA (1)
  • Nigeria (1)
  • non-union (11)
  • nuclear (3)
  • Oakland (5)
  • Obama (14)
  • occupy oakland (2)
  • occupy wall street (1)
  • oil industry (2)
  • OUSD (1)
  • Pakistan (3)
  • Pensions (2)
  • police brutality (6)
  • politicians (6)
  • politics (22)
  • pollution (11)
  • poverty (7)
  • prisons (8)
  • privatization (6)
  • profits (21)
  • protectionism (2)
  • public education (9)
  • public sector (15)
  • public workers (6)
  • racism (18)
  • rape (2)
  • Religion (10)
  • Russia (1)
  • San Leandro (2)
  • sexism (21)
  • sexual violence (2)
  • Snowden (7)
  • socialism (22)
  • soldiers (1)
  • solidarity (1)
  • South Africa (15)
  • Spain (2)
  • speculation (1)
  • sport (2)
  • strikes (35)
  • students (3)
  • surveillance (1)
  • Syria (9)
  • tax the rich (4)
  • taxes (1)
  • Teachers (6)
  • Team Concept (4)
  • terrorism (22)
  • the right (2)
  • Trayvon Martin (3)
  • turkey (3)
  • UAW (3)
  • unemployment (1)
  • union-busting (3)
  • unions (51)
  • US economy (22)
  • us elections (6)
  • US foreign policy (41)
  • US military (26)
  • veterans (1)
  • wall street criminals (13)
  • War (15)
  • wealth (9)
  • wikileaks (12)
  • women (26)
  • worker's party (2)
  • worker's struggle (65)
  • workers (44)
  • Workers International Network (1)
  • world economy (28)
  • youth (5)
  • Zionism (13)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (410)
    • ►  September (21)
    • ►  August (54)
    • ►  July (55)
    • ►  June (43)
    • ►  May (41)
    • ►  April (49)
    • ▼  March (56)
      • It’s still a bear market
      • Guantanamo Hunger Strikers Being Force Fed
      • Ireland: Working class history, Derry uprising 1969
      • South Africa -- Marikana, New Wave of Struggles --...
      • Profitability, the euro crisis and Icelandic myths
      • The 1% fleeing to tax havens with our money
      • The IDF: The "Most Moral Army in the World".
      • Working class history: The Derry Uprising 1969
      • Marx's ideas will not die
      • Zainab Al-Khawaja:Letter From A Bahraini Prison
      • European Union: Cyprus: sold!
      • South Africa: Cape Town Farmworkers' march
      • Zionists arresting Palestinian children
      • Politicians bought and paid for. Make them wear th...
      • Teachers are not to blame for education crisis; th...
      • Iraq War: A good investment for some
      • Rios Montt trial: Just one of the small fry.
      • South Africa: Miners Struggles---no job losses
      • Life is what we make it. Is that so?
      • Cambodians clash with cops over land grabs
      • Labor hierarchy abandons macho defense for shared ...
      • EuroZone: Cypriot bank heist
      • "Saint" Patricks so called day. An Irish Day.
      • Workers, punks and the euro crisis
      • CCSF rally against the cuts. Tim Paulson, Labor C...
      • Audio recording of Bradley Manning’s statement leaked
      • Break the lockout of ILWU by bosses in Vancouver WA
      • Pope. Last one and this one, viciously pro capital...
      • With Chavez gone, the vultures want back in.
      • It's easier to sign up for combat duty than for he...
      • Investment not consumption; profitability not demand
      • WIN Statement on Crisis in British SWP
      • Crisis in British SWP continues with resignations
      • Socialists and the Labor Bureacracy
      • South Africa: DLF on the legacy of Hugo Chavez
      • Ireland: Trade Union meeting in Dublin
      • The arrogance of Wall Street. From the Horses' Mouth
      • Pepsico wants Eastern Europeans to eat healthy snacks
      • Hugo Chavez funeral. Think about it this way.
      • Venezuela: Greg Palast on Hugo Chavez
      • Global Economy: World growth update
      • Chrysler attack on dissident is about who controls...
      • The Revolution Will Not Be Televised: Chavez, the ...
      • The end of Chavismo?
      • A moment with some relatives
      • War on Iran, War on Terror: No war on homelessness
      • Belgian MP slams War on Terror and Mali intervention
      • Students mired in a sea of debt
      • You can’t make a horse drink
      • Catholic Church. Do not be conned by the theatre a...
      • Chrysler attacks union dissident: UAW leadership d...
      • Wealth inequality in America
      • Palestinians living in an Apartheid state called I...
      • US prisons: Torture chambers
      • More crisis on the horizon as capitalism prepares ...
      • The other Mario and the other Marx
    • ►  February (46)
    • ►  January (45)
  • ►  2012 (90)
    • ►  December (43)
    • ►  November (47)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile